ACS Result Received (Unsuitable)

barricade · November 2019

Hello guys,

I need your inputs on this result. I find it weird, bakit unsuitable ako. Eh yung work ko mismo tama naman as Network Engineer.

Ano po kaya pwede kong gawin at sabihin sa ACS para machallenge etong result? Thank you so much.

Thank you for your ICT skills assessment, which was received by the Australian Computer Society on **
October 2019.

Your ICT skills have been assessed to be unsuitable for migration under ANZSCO Code 263111 (Computer
Network and Systems Engineer).

You have been assessed as not meeting the requirements for professional information technology
experience of six (6) years after the relevant qualification in a field closely related to your nominated skilled
occupation.

Your qualification has been assessed as follows:
Your Bachelor of Science in Computer Science from Holy Trinity College completed April 2009 has
been assessed as comparable to an AQF Associate Degree with a Major in computing.

Your work experience has been calculated as follows on the basis of full time employment of at least 20hrs
per week:

Dates: 06/10 - 01/12 - 1 year(s) 7 month(s)
Position: Sol. Support Engr
Employer: *********
Country: Outside Of Australia

Dates: 03/13 - 05/16 - 3 year(s) 2 month(s)
Position: Post-Sales Engr
Employer: **********
Country: Outside Of Australia

Dates: 05/19 - 08/19 - 0 year(s) 3 month(s) ** -correct ay 05/16 to 08/19**
Position: Network Admin Sup
Employer: ************
Country: Outside Of Australia

RheaMARN1171933 · November 2019

From what I understand, you didn’t have enough work experience. Your qualification is equivalent to an associate degree only so this means you need at least 6 years experience to get a successful outcome

barricade · November 2019

@RheaMARN1171933 said:
From what I understand, you didn’t have enough work experience. Your qualification is equivalent to an associate degree only so this means you need at least 6 years experience to get a successful outcome..

hmmm.. mukhang tama po kayo...

Is there anything you can suggest? lungkot associate degree lang binigay sakin. makukuha ba ito if i appealed sa result na with explanation/letter baka magawa nilang baguhin yung result?

Kasi yung course ko BS in Computer Science, tapos Network Engineering ang naging work ko.
Pero ang mga network engineers naman kasi walang closely related yan na purely Network Engineering ang tinuturo sa school... even in Information Technology course, its a mix of programming, systems, and other subjects. Yang major ko we even had a Networking subject and also Servers/Computer systems, although mas lamang nga lang talaga ang programming, but to think.. sa Network Engineering required ang programming eh, like Python, Perl, Ruby..

Sana meron pa ibang makapag input ng thoughts nila Thanks!

RheaMARN1171933 · November 2019

The issue is more on your qualification which they’ve no got say. They can’t decide on the equivalence of your degree to AQF since they just follow the Country education profile. No point appealing too. You just need to accumulate at least 6 years experience

_sebodemacho · November 2019

@barricade hmmm share ko lang yung tingin ko mga rason bakit ganon yung resulta ng assessment mo:

yung university/college where you graduated from. meron syang bearing since your school is in Section 2, if im not mistaken, kaya rin Associate level lang yung equivalent sa AQF nung course mo. so, nagbawas pa sila dun sa years of experience mo (see ACS guidelines on Skilled Date Met)
yung work experience mo as Network Engineer, medyo nalayo from your course in college. may bearing rin yun... although di naman ganon malayo, but then you're applying for 263111 (Computer
Network and Systems Engineer, bakak naghahanap sila na IT graduate or Computer Engineering talaga.
and lastly, more on your work experience pa rin, try to check your employment reference that you submitted. baka yung description ng job responsibilities ay hindi ganon ka-detail? as much as possible dapat point for point clear in relation to the ANZSCO code you're applying for.

barricade · November 2019

@_sebodemacho said:
@barricade hmmm share ko lang yung tingin ko mga rason bakit ganon yung resulta ng assessment mo:

yung university/college where you graduated from. meron syang bearing since your school is in Section 2, if im not mistaken, kaya rin Associate level lang yung equivalent sa AQF nung course mo. so, nagbawas pa sila dun sa years of experience mo (see ACS guidelines on Skilled Date Met)

yung work experience mo as Network Engineer, medyo nalayo from your course in college. may bearing rin yun... although di naman ganon malayo, but then you're applying for 263111 (Computer
Network and Systems Engineer, bakak naghahanap sila na IT graduate or Computer Engineering talaga.

and lastly, more on your work experience pa rin, try to check your employment reference that you submitted. baka yung description ng job responsibilities ay hindi ganon ka-detail? as much as possible dapat point for point clear in relation to the ANZSCO code you're applying for.

I agree with 1 & 2. Sa 3 im sure i got this right.

Thanks for the inputs. Appreciate it. Naisuperior ko nga PTE ko dito naman sumabit, malas. Definitely not my day. I guess ill just add 1 more year sa exp ko at mag take ng CCNP.

barricade · November 2019

For anyone who is curious.. there's a plot twist!

Update!

So i emailed ACS. Apparently i was right - there was something weird about the result.

This was a typo on their end.

Dates: 05/19 - 08/19 - 0 year(s) 3 month(s)
Position: Network Admin Sup
Employer: ************
Country: Outside Of Australia

They emailed me a new result, which is now _suitable _ but they deducted 6 years out of 8 years of experience. so i get 0 points lol. but still "suitable". My english test is Proficient, so medyo nahatak.

Alright!

ms_ane · November 2019

@barricade said:
For anyone who is curious.. there's a plot twist!

Update!

So i emailed ACS. Apparently i was right - there was something weird about the result.

This was a typo on their end.

Dates: 05/19 - 08/19 - 0 year(s) 3 month(s)
Position: Network Admin Sup
Employer: ************
Country: Outside Of Australia

They emailed me a new result, which is now _suitable _ but they deducted 6 years out of 8 years of experience. so i get 0 points lol. but still "suitable". My english test is Proficient, so medyo nahatak.

Alright!

O diba, worthwhile na nagtanong ka, mas sobrang ok na ang suitable na outcome. Congrats kapatid

barricade · November 2019

@ms_ane said:

@barricade said:
For anyone who is curious.. there's a plot twist!

Update!

So i emailed ACS. Apparently i was right - there was something weird about the result.

This was a typo on their end.

Dates: 05/19 - 08/19 - 0 year(s) 3 month(s)
Position: Network Admin Sup
Employer: ************
Country: Outside Of Australia

They emailed me a new result, which is now _suitable _ but they deducted 6 years out of 8 years of experience. so i get 0 points lol. but still "suitable". My english test is Proficient, so medyo nahatak.

Alright!

O diba, worthwhile na nagtanong ka, mas sobrang ok na ang suitable na outcome. Congrats kapatid

oo nga! kulit din ng ACS, mali-mali din minsan haha.

Pasok ako sa Regional 85 pts, kaso negative sa 189 and 190. kulang points ;/

mandark_d_gray · November 2019

@barricade said:

@ms_ane said:

@barricade said:
For anyone who is curious.. there's a plot twist!

Update!

So i emailed ACS. Apparently i was right - there was something weird about the result.

This was a typo on their end.

Dates: 05/19 - 08/19 - 0 year(s) 3 month(s)
Position: Network Admin Sup
Employer: ************
Country: Outside Of Australia

They emailed me a new result, which is now _suitable _ but they deducted 6 years out of 8 years of experience. so i get 0 points lol. but still "suitable". My english test is Proficient, so medyo nahatak.

Alright!

O diba, worthwhile na nagtanong ka, mas sobrang ok na ang suitable na outcome. Congrats kapatid

oo nga! kulit din ng ACS, mali-mali din minsan haha.

Pasok ako sa Regional 85 pts, kaso negative sa 189 and 190. kulang points ;/

Sir question lang...ano na ba required points ngayon para ma consider na mabigyan ng ITA? 85 points but not enough for 189 or 190?

_sebodemacho · November 2019

oo nga! kulit din ng ACS, mali-mali din minsan haha.

Pasok ako sa Regional 85 pts, kaso negative sa 189 and 190. kulang points ;/

Ahahaha! At least pasok sa Regional. Buti na lang rin nag file ka ng appeal. Nice, congrats pa rin!

_sebodemacho · November 2019

@mandark_d_gray said:

@barricade said:

@ms_ane said:

@barricade said:
For anyone who is curious.. there's a plot twist!

Update!

So i emailed ACS. Apparently i was right - there was something weird about the result.

This was a typo on their end.

Dates: 05/19 - 08/19 - 0 year(s) 3 month(s)
Position: Network Admin Sup
Employer: ************
Country: Outside Of Australia

They emailed me a new result, which is now _suitable _ but they deducted 6 years out of 8 years of experience. so i get 0 points lol. but still "suitable". My english test is Proficient, so medyo nahatak.

Alright!

O diba, worthwhile na nagtanong ka, mas sobrang ok na ang suitable na outcome. Congrats kapatid

oo nga! kulit din ng ACS, mali-mali din minsan haha.

Pasok ako sa Regional 85 pts, kaso negative sa 189 and 190. kulang points ;/

Sir question lang...ano na ba required points ngayon para ma consider na mabigyan ng ITA? 85 points but not enough for 189 or 190?

Yes, 85 and up na. At para lang maconsider pa yan ha, hindi pa sureball. Pahirapan na ngayon

barricade · November 2019

Sir question lang...ano na ba required points ngayon para ma consider na mabigyan ng ITA? 85 points but not enough for 189 or 190?

Yes, 85 and up na. At para lang maconsider pa yan ha, hindi pa sureball. Pahirapan na ngayon

Oo kasi nadagdagan din yung points sa partner or single section..

mandark_d_gray · November 2019

@_sebodemacho said:

@mandark_d_gray said:

@barricade said:

@ms_ane said:

@barricade said:
For anyone who is curious.. there's a plot twist!

Update!

So i emailed ACS. Apparently i was right - there was something weird about the result.

This was a typo on their end.

Dates: 05/19 - 08/19 - 0 year(s) 3 month(s)
Position: Network Admin Sup
Employer: ************
Country: Outside Of Australia

They emailed me a new result, which is now _suitable _ but they deducted 6 years out of 8 years of experience. so i get 0 points lol. but still "suitable". My english test is Proficient, so medyo nahatak.

Alright!

O diba, worthwhile na nagtanong ka, mas sobrang ok na ang suitable na outcome. Congrats kapatid

oo nga! kulit din ng ACS, mali-mali din minsan haha.

Pasok ako sa Regional 85 pts, kaso negative sa 189 and 190. kulang points ;/

Sir question lang...ano na ba required points ngayon para ma consider na mabigyan ng ITA? 85 points but not enough for 189 or 190?

Yes, 85 and up na. At para lang maconsider pa yan ha, hindi pa sureball. Pahirapan na ngayon

Thank you sa info. I understand pahirapan na talaga ngayon, so this 85 and above is "unofficial", correct? Kasi sa DHA website minimum 65 points pa rin requirement?

_sebodemacho · November 2019

@mandark_d_gray said:

@_sebodemacho said:

@mandark_d_gray said:

@barricade said:

@ms_ane said:

@barricade said:
For anyone who is curious.. there's a plot twist!

Update!

So i emailed ACS. Apparently i was right - there was something weird about the result.

This was a typo on their end.

Dates: 05/19 - 08/19 - 0 year(s) 3 month(s)
Position: Network Admin Sup
Employer: ************
Country: Outside Of Australia

They emailed me a new result, which is now _suitable _ but they deducted 6 years out of 8 years of experience. so i get 0 points lol. but still "suitable". My english test is Proficient, so medyo nahatak.

Alright!

O diba, worthwhile na nagtanong ka, mas sobrang ok na ang suitable na outcome. Congrats kapatid

oo nga! kulit din ng ACS, mali-mali din minsan haha.

Pasok ako sa Regional 85 pts, kaso negative sa 189 and 190. kulang points ;/

Sir question lang...ano na ba required points ngayon para ma consider na mabigyan ng ITA? 85 points but not enough for 189 or 190?

Yes, 85 and up na. At para lang maconsider pa yan ha, hindi pa sureball. Pahirapan na ngayon

Thank you sa info. I understand pahirapan na talaga ngayon, so this 85 and above is "unofficial", correct? Kasi sa DHA website minimum 65 points pa rin requirement?

65 pts kasi na yan, that's only for you to be eligible to lodge an Expression of Interest (EOI). But then, higher the points the higher you chance to get invited. So, you have to aim for more than 65.

And yun nga, nowadays, 85 and up na yung nai-invite..

RheaMARN1171933 · November 2019

@barricade congrats. Yes, it’s always worth raising things with them vs here on the forum as they could see a clearer picture than the snippets of information one provides on this forum.

plasticeye · January 2020

@_sebodemacho said:

@mandark_d_gray said:

@barricade said:

@ms_ane said:

@barricade said:
For anyone who is curious.. there's a plot twist!

Update!

So i emailed ACS. Apparently i was right - there was something weird about the result.

This was a typo on their end.

Dates: 05/19 - 08/19 - 0 year(s) 3 month(s)
Position: Network Admin Sup
Employer: ************
Country: Outside Of Australia

They emailed me a new result, which is now _suitable _ but they deducted 6 years out of 8 years of experience. so i get 0 points lol. but still "suitable". My english test is Proficient, so medyo nahatak.

Alright!

O diba, worthwhile na nagtanong ka, mas sobrang ok na ang suitable na outcome. Congrats kapatid

oo nga! kulit din ng ACS, mali-mali din minsan haha.

Pasok ako sa Regional 85 pts, kaso negative sa 189 and 190. kulang points ;/

Sir question lang...ano na ba required points ngayon para ma consider na mabigyan ng ITA? 85 points but not enough for 189 or 190?

Yes, 85 and up na. At para lang maconsider pa yan ha, hindi pa sureball. Pahirapan na ngayon